The case of Susan McGowan was extraordinary – even for Brisbane of the late 1800s with its prolific and unremitting petty crime.
As today, the nineteenth-century Brisbane city centre hosted an array of public houses, shops, hotels. Pugh’s Queensland Almanac listed an extraordinary number of businesses in the district. As early as 1864, a number of areas most susceptible to disorderly conduct and assaults begin to appear, with the city centre being one of them. Queen-Street, North Quay and their immediate vicinity stand out for the number of drunkenness and petty assaults charges. Along with the latter, this central commercial district of the city was extremely inviting to street urchins, thieves, and prostitutes. According to the daily police court proceedings, a noteworthy number of cases originated from this area of Brisbane.
The case of Susan McGowan, a lady of negotiable affections, is a particularly striking example of the more or less routine cases borne out of this vicinity. She first made her appearance in January, 1885:
Two months later, after her first appearance in January, Susan McGowan was assaulted again in March in Margaret Street:From the evidence for the prosecution it appears that Susan M’Gowan was standing in Margaret-street when the accused came out of a yard and threw a piece of road metal at her, striking in the head and knocking her down; he then went up to her and kicked her once in a face and once in the leg. [Brisbane Courier, 19 March 1885]
Ms McGowan’s second assailant appeared on three separate charges that day. Apart from assaulting Susan McGowan, Patrick Brittain was charged with being drunk and disorderly in Albert Street and with destroying Police uniform value of 21l. [City Police Court Minutes, 1885].
Hardly two months passed before McGowan appeared in the Police Court once again, in which she was assaulted by Margaret Corkery, in the same location, in Margaret-Street.
‘From the evidence it appeared that the complainant was severely beaten by the accused. The assault arose out of some ill-feeling created by a recent case. The bench found the prisoner guilty, and sentenced her to two months’ imprisonment. [Brisbane Courier, 8 May 1885]
Overall, Ms McGowan was assaulted at least five times within six months, as she made two more cameo appearances in the courts in the coming months of June and July; both times assaults took place on Albert-Street. [Brisbane Courier, 5 June 1885 and 4 July 1885]
Though the central streets of Brisbane were notorious for petty crime, Susan McGowan’s astounding example of bad luck was undoubtedly out of the ordinary.
__________________
This information has been supplied by the Queensland Police Museum from the 2012 PHD thesis “Crime and Policing in Dublin, Brisbane and London c1850-1900” with the kind approval of the author Dr Anastasia Dukova.
The Police Museum is open 9am to 4pm Monday to Friday and 10am to 3pm on the last Sunday of the month (Feb-Nov) and is located on the Ground Floor of Police Headquarters at 200 Roma Street, Brisbane. Contact: E: museum@police.qld.gov.au
“FROM THE VAULT: A Story of One Unlucky Susan M’Gowan” by the Queensland Police Service is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution (BY) 2.5 Australia Licence. Permissions may be available beyond the scope of this licence. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.5/au/legalcode… Continue reading